Best Tartar Sauce of 2025

“This is the best tartar sauce I have ever tried! I’m so happy I discovered it, and it’s the only brand I will buy from now on. Highly recommended!”

“I find this sauce to be very flavorful and a bit stronger than McDonald's, which I love. I just add a little mayo to achieve the perfect blend, but it is a little expensive.”

“I had a very fast delivery on this product, but that’s the only positive. It arrived completely separated and oily, looking like curdled vomit. I wouldn’t even consider opening it.”

"As someone picky about tartar sauce, I usually make my own. However, this one is surprisingly good—very mild and reminds me of McDonald's tartar sauce. I can see why others are loyal to it, and I'm excited to try it with french fries!"

"Being from Toledo and now living in Florida, I really miss Frisch's Big Boys. I ordered this sauce for a copycat burger and received it quickly. My husband couldn't stop eating—he's already asking for burgers again soon!"

"Since Frisch's Big Boy isn't nearby, I was thrilled to find this tartar sauce on Amazon. It’s perfect for sandwiches and burgers, and even my toddler enjoys it on its own. The jars are nice and easy to reuse!"

"I will definitely buy from this vendor again because I was pleased with the fast delivery. I use this for my gatherings."

"I used this product for a fish fry, and it made everything much easier. Plus, the taste was really good!"

"This tartar sauce tastes fantastic, just like what you'd find in seafood restaurants. I'm a satisfied buyer!"

"This is my favorite tartar sauce, and I'm thrilled I found it on Amazon since I can't find it in stores anymore."

"While it's not as good as homemade, it definitely serves its purpose when I'm short on time or ingredients."

"I decided to try this sauce after my usual brand was out of stock. I was pleasantly surprised by its taste and would buy this brand again if needed."

"I absolutely love the ingredients in this sauce. It's just how tartar sauce should taste!"

"This is my first time trying this tartar sauce, and I really like it. My wife, who usually dislikes tartar sauce, enjoys this one because of the horseradish touch!"

"I remember Bookbinder's restaurant in Philadelphia as one of the best seafood places. If this tartar sauce is anything like the restaurant, it's sure to fly off the shelves!"

"When I first saw it, I was surprised by the size; it's so tiny that I could easily hide it in my hands. The flavor was initially strong but not overwhelming. As I continued eating, the strong sourness faded, and it turned out to be a great tartar sauce. Overall, I rate it 5/5, but the jar size is a bit too small for my liking when I prefer more dressing with my food."

"Honestly, I don't understand the rave reviews. This tartar sauce has a very strong mustard flavor, which wasn't what I was expecting. If you're a fan of mustard, it might be perfect for you! I personally found a tartar sauce I love much more—Suzie's Organic Tartar Sauce—which has a delightful dill flavor without being overpowering. But, I guess taste is subjective!"

"I've been searching for a good tartar sauce for a long time, and I found this one. It has a unique sweet/dill flavor that I wasn't expecting. While it's quite expensive for such a small jar, it's still interesting. I remember the days when fish and chip shops had the best tartar sauces. Although I appreciate this one, I will continue my search for the perfect tartar sauce!"

"I have tried several tartar sauces, and this one is the best I've encountered. It’s not only delicious but also comes in a great size at a fantastic price!"

"As someone who loves tartar sauce on fish and scallops, I found this one from 365 to be really enjoyable. The flavor is fresh, and while it’s more mayonnaise-like than chunky, it works well for me. I’ll definitely buy more once I run out!"

"I was thrilled to find one of the few organic tartar sauces available, and it's also reasonably priced. The taste is pretty good too!"

“After becoming a strict Vegan due to severe kidney disease, I was on the lookout for products that would enhance my Vegan meals without added sugar and salt. I tried the Sweet and Sour Sauce with my Vegan spring rolls, and it was sensational! I've also used it on other dishes, like a bland bean bowl, and it made everything delicious. Plus, being sugar-free with only 10 calories per 2 tablespoons is a huge win for me! I've subscribed to get it monthly so it's always on hand!”

“As a fan of G. Hughes sauces, I expected the Sweet and Sour Sauce to be great, and it did not disappoint! It allows people with diabetes to enjoy a delightful Sweet and Sour Chicken dinner. I recommend it over hot Birds Eye frozen cauliflower rice or a bit of brown basmati rice—it’s a perfect meal!”

“I was pleasantly surprised by how tasty this sauce is. Being sugar-free, it fits perfectly into my diabetic diet and weight loss plan.”

"As a 70-year-old, I'm really impressed! This is the best tartar sauce I've tasted. It beats all those mayo-heavy products. The flavor is so good, I can't resist sopping it up with my fish!"

"While I usually make my own tartar sauce, I decided to try this one based on a recommendation. It's not quite as good as my homemade version, but it's nice to have on hand for those times I don't have all the ingredients ready. A handy option to keep on the shelf!"

"This tartar sauce is just what I was looking for, reminiscent of New England flavors! Excellent flavor and consistency make it terrific on clam strips. Yum!"

"This is the best tartar sauce out there. As a pescatarian, I go through a lot of tartar sauce, and this one has a rich relish taste that puts all others to shame. I just wish Heinz still sold it in plastic containers—what's up with that?"

"I've tried several tartar sauces, but they all fall short compared to this one. Yes, I did buy these single-serve packets for my house! If you want to join me for dinner and tease me about it, I don’t mind at all!"

"As a frequent traveler, I've been to places where I wished they served tartar sauce with fish. These packets are a great idea since I can't carry a bottle. The sauce tastes the same and is portable, and I am so glad it's available."