Best Pumpernickel Sandwich Bread of 2025

Ashley Abels Avatar
Ashley Abels
Last Updated: Jan 4, 2025

* We independently evaluate all recommended products and services. If you click on links we provide, we may receive compensation.

Pumpernickel sandwich bread is a delicious and hearty bread that is perfect for making sandwiches. This bread is made from a combination of rye flour, wheat flour, and molasses, which gives it a rich, slightly sweet flavor. Pumpernickel bread is also known for its dark color and dense texture, making it a great choice for sandwiches that need a sturdy base. Whether you're making a classic pastrami sandwich or a veggie sandwich with avocado and sprouts, pumpernickel bread is sure to add a delicious and unique flavor to your meal.

At a Glance: Our Top Picks

Stern's Bakery Pumpernickel Bread - 2 Pack Cover#TOP 1
Stern's Bakery Pumpernickel Bread - 2 Pack
ftb score rating icon9.8
Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread Cover#TOP 2
Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread
ftb score rating icon9.7
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread Cover#TOP 3
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread
ftb score rating icon9.5

Top 10 Pumpernickel Sandwich Bread

Stern's Bakery Pumpernickel Bread - 2 Pack

1 Pound (Pack of 2)
Stern's Bakery Pumpernickel Bread - 2 Pack Cover
Pumpernickel Bread -2 Pack-16 oz Per Loaf | Delicious Sandwich Bread | Kosher Bread | Fresh Bread | Dairy & Nut Free | Stern’s Bakery
ftb score rating icon9.8
FTB Score

Stern's Bakery Pumpernickel Bread is a delicious and fluffy pre-sliced sandwich bread made from high-quality ingredients. This dairy-free, nut-free bread is kosher certified by the CRC and comes in a dedicated bread bag to preserve its optimum quality and freshness. It is perfect for breakfast, sandwiches on the go, or to complement your holiday meals. Stern's Bakery is committed to providing only the finest quality bread for over a century.

What We Like
Pre-sliced for easy use
Kosher certified by the CRC and dairy-free, nut-free, and soy-free
Baked fresh daily from high-quality ingredients
#TOP 2

Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread

00636233
Pumpernickel
Mestemacher Pumpernickel Bread Cover
Mestemacher Bread, Pumpernickel, 17.6 Oz, Pack of 12
ftb score rating icon9.7
FTB Score

Mestemacher Pumpernickel is a dark and dense traditional German bread that is packed with whole grain goodness, making it a great choice for those following a health-conscious diet. Its slightly sweet rye flavor adds a delicious twist to any meal or snack. With its certified organic ingredients and no preservatives, it is suitable for vegans and vegetarians. This bread also has a low glycemic index, providing a fast and filling alternative to regular bread. It is high in fiber and low in cholesterol, with each slice containing 9 grams of fiber. The long shelf life of up to 6 months ensures you can enjoy this nutritious bread for a long time.

What We Like
High nutrition
Big on taste
Certified organic
#TOP 3

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread

pack of 2
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread Cover
Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread (Pumpernickel, 17.6 oz, pack of 2)
ftb score rating icon9.5
FTB Score

Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread is a high-fiber bread that comes in a pack of two. It is made from 100% whole grain and contains no preservatives. This bread is perfect for toasting, allowing you to enjoy a delicious and crunchy breakfast or snack. With 17.6 oz of whole grain per pack, it is a great source of fiber, which can help promote a healthy digestive system and keep you feeling full for longer. Additionally, this bread is kosher and certified by the Whole Grain Council, ensuring its quality and authenticity. Mestemacher Whole Grain Bread is a nutritious and convenient choice for those looking for a wholesome and tasty bread option.

What We Like
High fiber
No preservatives
Kosher
#TOP 4

Generic Deli Swirl Rye & Pumpernickel Bread

Generic
Generic Deli Swirl Rye & Pumpernickel Bread Cover
Generic Pepperidge Farm Jewish Rye and Pumpernickel Deli Swirl Bread, 2 lbs.
ftb score rating icon9.4
FTB Score

Generic Deli Swirl Bread offers a delightful blend of rye and pumpernickel, making it a versatile choice for your meals. This unique combination is perfect for toasting, enhancing your breakfast or snack experience. When you're in the mood for a hearty sandwich, this bread is an excellent option for classic recipes like a reuben or pastrami, providing a rich flavor that complements your favorite fillings. Its 2-pound size ensures you have enough to satisfy your cravings, whether you're serving a crowd or enjoying it solo.

What We Like
Unique flavor combination
Ideal for sandwiches
Great for toasting
Generous 2-pound size
#TOP 5

Gourmet Market German Pumpernickel Bread

Gourmet Market German Pumpernickel Bread Cover
German Pumpernickel Bread Pack Of 2
ftb score rating icon9.3
FTB Score

The Gourmet Market Pumpernickel Bread comes in a convenient pack of two, freshly baked in one of New York's top bakeries. This bread is ideal for creating delicious sandwiches, making it a favorite among many delis and bagel shops in NYC. You will appreciate that the bread is shipped the same day it's baked, ensuring you receive it as fresh as possible. With a shelf life of 30 days, you can also freeze it to extend its freshness up to six months, allowing you to enjoy it at your convenience.

What We Like
Freshly baked quality
Ideal for sandwiches
Quick shipping
Long shelf life
#TOP 6

Rye Bread Variety Bundle - Stern's Bakery

1 Pound (Pack of 3)
Rye Bread Variety Bundle - Stern's Bakery Cover
Rye Bread | 3 Flavor Variety Bundle | (1) Seeded Rye Bread, (1) Real Jewish Rye Bread ( Seedless) & (1) Pumpernickel Bread | 2-3 Day Shipping |16 oz per Loaf - Stern's Bakery [ 3 Loaves of Bread Included ]
ftb score rating icon9.3
FTB Score

The Rye Bread Variety Bundle from Stern's Bakery includes three loaves of pre-sliced bread - Seeded Rye, Real Jewish Rye (seedless), and Pumpernickel. The bread is made from high-grade ingredients, baked fresh daily, and is preservative-free. It is also kosher certified by OK & CRC. A perfect hassle-free breakfast or lunch option for rye bread lovers.

What We Like
Three different flavors included in the bundle
Bread is baked fresh daily
High-grade ingredients used with no preservatives
#TOP 7

S.Rosen's Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel

S. Rosen's
S.Rosen's Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel Cover
S.Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread - Pumpernickel (Case of 4 Loaves)
ftb score rating icon9.3
FTB Score

S.Rosen's Pumpernickel Bread is perfect for creating tiny sandwiches for your next party. The mini 2.5" square bread slices are ideal for appetizers. With 35 slices per loaf, each serving includes 5 slices, making it convenient for serving a crowd. Additionally, this bread is shipped once a week on Monday mornings, ensuring freshness when you order by Thursday. Enjoy the convenience of preparing delightful appetizers or tiny sandwiches effortlessly with S.Rosen's Pumpernickel Bread.

What We Like
Great for party sandwiches
Mini slices for appetizers
Convenient serving size
#TOP 8

Marble Rye Bread by Gourmet Market

4 Count (Pack of 1)
Marble Rye Bread by Gourmet Market Cover
Marble Rye Bread Pack of 4
ftb score rating icon9.3
FTB Score

Gourmet Market Marble Rye offers a delicious pack of four half loaves, perfect for your sandwich needs. Made from scratch in a reputable New York bakery, this all-natural and sugar-free bread features a unique blend of rye and pumpernickel flours. You’ll appreciate the convenience of pre-sliced loaves, making it easy to prepare your favorite sandwiches or pair with meals. Plus, with same-day baking, you can enjoy the fresh taste straight from the oven, ensuring quality and flavor in every bite.

What We Like
Freshly baked for superior taste
Convenient pre-sliced loaves
All-natural, sugar-free ingredients
Perfect for sandwiches and meals
#TOP 9

New York's Finest Bakery Marble Rye Bread Pack

Generic
New York's Finest Bakery Marble Rye Bread Pack Cover
Marble Rye Bread Pack of 4
ftb score rating icon9.3
FTB Score

New York's Finest Bakery Marble Rye Bread Pack is a pack of 4 half loaves of deli-style Jewish marble rye bread. This bread is favored by famous delis and sandwich shops in NYC. It is all-natural, sugar-free, and made from scratch with quality ingredients. The bread is freshly baked and delivered the same day to ensure freshness. Enjoy a great tasting sandwich or pair it with any meal for a delicious experience.

What We Like
Authentic flavor
Freshly baked
All-natural ingredients
#TOP 10

S. Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread, 4 Loaves

Generic
7Y-J9QZ-RJZK
S. Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread, 4 Loaves Cover
S. Rosens Cocktail Rye Bread, Case of 4 Loaves, 2 each of Caraway and Pumpernickel, 12 oz each loaf
ftb score rating icon9.1
FTB Score

S. Rosens Rye Bread offers a convenient solution for your appetizer needs with its pre-sliced tiny squares. You can simply thaw the slices and have them ready for use, saving you time in the kitchen. These bite-sized pieces allow for various toppings, so you can create a delightful snack that’s easy to enjoy. Perfect for parties, these pre-portioned slices make arranging appetizers a breeze, eliminating mess and fuss. Crafted with high-quality rye flour, this bread serves as an excellent base for any savory spread or cheese, enhancing your entertaining experience.

What We Like
Pre-sliced for convenience
Quick thawing for easy use
Bite-sized for versatile toppings
Ideal for entertaining
Buying Guide Image

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is pumpernickel bread a healthy bread?

Pumpernickel bread is considered a healthy bread option due to its dark crust, which is rich in vitamins and antioxidants. It is an enriched source of nutrients and has a coarse texture with a slightly sweet taste profile, making it a recommended addition to a balanced diet.

2. What goes well with pumpernickel bread?

Pumpernickel bread pairs well with various ingredients. It complements corned beef, pastrami, hot dogs, roast pork, roast beef, cheddar cheese, salad, tuna fish, chopped liver, and egg salad. Its unique flavor and texture enhance the overall taste and experience of these combinations.

3. What do Germans eat with pumpernickel bread?

Germans enjoy pumpernickel bread with slices of roast beef, ham, or smoked salmon topped with creamy horseradish. They also add tomatoes, cucumbers, and a slice of mild cheese to create a contrast of freshness and crispness with the moist, hearty bread.

4. Is pumpernickel bread high in sugar?

Pumpernickel bread is low in sugar compared to white bread. While a regular slice of white bread provides about 1.6 grams of sugar, pumpernickel bread contains only 0.2 grams of sugar. Additionally, pumpernickel bread offers over 2 grams of fiber, making it a healthier choice.

5. Why does pumpernickel bread taste so good?

The dark brown color and earthy, slightly sweet taste of pumpernickel bread make it unique and delicious. Spices like caraway and onion add an exotic bite to the bread, enhancing its flavor. Pumpernickel bread is dense, hearty, and does not have a crust, which adds to its appeal.

6. Is pumpernickel bread hard to digest?

Pumpernickel bread has a dense texture, which has led to its German name meaning 'hard to digest.' While there may be some debate about the origin of the name, the density of the bread can make it more challenging to digest compared to lighter bread options.

7. Which is healthier, rye bread or pumpernickel?

Rye bread is generally considered healthier than pumpernickel bread due to its higher amount of soluble fiber. Soluble fiber helps lower cholesterol levels by binding to cholesterol in the digestive system, reducing its absorption into the bloodstream. This can contribute to a reduced risk of heart disease.

Editor's Notes

During our pumpernickel sandwich bread research, we found 24 pumpernickel sandwich bread products and shortlisted 10 quality products. We collected and analyzed 6,131 customer reviews through our big data system to write the pumpernickel sandwich bread list. We found that most customers choose pumpernickel sandwich bread with an average price of $29.35.

The pumpernickel sandwich bread are available for purchase. We have researched hundreds of brands and picked the top brands of pumpernickel sandwich bread, including Stern's Bakery, Mestemacher, Gourmet Market, S. Rosen's. The seller of top 1 product has received honest feedback from 868 consumers with an average rating of 4.8.

Written by
Ashley Abels Avatar

Ashley Abels is a former restaurant executive and has worked in the restaurant industry for 15 years. She is also a gourmet who loves tasting different cuisines and trying out all kinds of cooking methods. The food she writes about will make you want to try it!