Best Peanut-Butter Cookies of 2025

"During my pregnancy, I’ve been craving these bite-sized Nutter Butters. I prefer these smaller ones over the larger size, but I often struggle to find them in grocery stores. They’re available at gas stations for around $2.99 to $3.50 per bag, so ordering this box with 12 bags was a great money-saving choice. They taste amazing and really satisfy my cravings!"

"I ordered these mini cookies for my daughter's baby shower to create cute acorns with chocolate Kisses. They were not only delicious but also adorable! Thankfully, the cookies arrived in excellent shape with very few broken ones. We even had leftover bags, which means they are perfect for sharing or a generous snack!"

"I find these mini cookies to be perfect for trips and vacations since my kids love their size. They’re fresh and just right for a quick snack. I even shared some with a couple of little boys, and they devoured the whole bag in no time!"

"I love the strong peanut butter flavor. These cookies are always fresh when they arrive, and I can't believe how quickly they were delivered!"

"I was pleasantly surprised by the great value. Getting 12 packages for just $4.44 each was a steal, especially considering how delicious these cookies are!"

"While the new crunchy texture is a bit different, I still enjoy them. I just wish they were still in the peanut shape like before."

"These are some of the best cookies I've found anywhere. Fresh, soft, and taste GREAT!"

"I love this brand. Normally, they're nice and soft, but I might have received an off batch this time."

"I was introduced to Matt's cookies at an entrepreneur club meeting in Chicago. I was blown away and have never forgotten how good they are."

"I was thrilled when my three packages arrived on time and in great condition. It's hard to find these goodies in supermarkets!"

"This crunchy treat is a favorite of mine, but I was disappointed to find many of the cookies crushed and stale. My previous orders were fresh and delicious."

"These arrived just as I expected! They are a fantastic snack for my grandmother; she absolutely loves them!"

"I ordered the Amazon fulfilled 60 count box, and it arrived today. The expiration date on the biscuits is October 2017, which I can manage. None of the biscuits were broken, so the carrier handled the box well. They felt soft and looked authentic. After having two biscuits, I found they tasted just like the ones from the market. While they aren't the ultimate peanut butter cookies, for fifty cents a pack, they offer great value. They're ideal for lunches or snacks and pair wonderfully with cold milk. I believe this brand surpasses most grocery store biscuits."

"These are the famous Grandma's cookies that everyone loves! They're super soft and fresh, and definitely worth every penny. Given the amount in each pack, the price is an awesome steal! My family adores them, so I’ll definitely be ordering again!"

"I must admit, I got a bit tipsy and ordered these cookies. It turns out, it's not just 60 cookies; it's 60 packs with 2 cookies each, totaling 120 cookies! They taste fantastic and are of good quality, though they are quite rich. I ended up eating more than I should have, and it left me feeling a bit sick. However, the savings are remarkable. Just a heads up—each pack has nearly 400 calories, so be cautious!"

"I thought I'd give these a try and they're that good! I even bought some gourmet vanilla ice cream to enjoy with them. They’re so good, I won’t share! I received my first box just three days ago and ordered another tonight!"

"I used to love Mrs. Fields, but they’re hard to find in stores. One day at work, I discovered these magnificent cookies in the break room. I’m a sucker for soft chocolate chip cookies, and after just 15 seconds in the microwave, I was in heaven! I bought the rest on the shelf and realized it’s cheaper to buy online. I haven’t tried the other flavors yet, but I’m ordering more now!"

"I live in Tennessee where these cookies are made, and they are so good! I’ve bought these classic cookies many times online and love them!"

“I love a good dense, chewy texture for soft baked cookies, and these definitely satisfy! There's a generous amount of chocolate chunks and a good peanut butter flavor too. They are super dense and chewy straight out of the bag, and slightly warming them in the microwave makes them softer and more gooey depending on the time and power level. My favorite cookies!”

“I just absolutely love them. They have just the right type of crunchy.”

“For a vegan cookie, it's pretty good. A nice, tasty snack.”

"I find it hard to locate these delicious cookies, but the quick delivery impressed me. I will definitely order again!"

"I purchase these for my husband because you can't beat the price. They are fresh and individually packed, so he can enjoy them at his own pace. It’s great that it’s not a combo package like at big-box stores!"

"I ordered these cookies to share with my family. Although they were good, they didn’t quite match the quality of those from my grocery store. The packages seemed a bit dry and had a slightly odd taste."

"These cookies are one of my favorite snacks; the sweetness is just right! I ordered four packs and I absolutely recommend trying them!"

"I enjoy these cookies with my coffee; it's great to have them delivered directly to my door!"

"Every morning, I eat Nekot's with my coffee; I love the convenience of Amazon delivery and these little cookies are perfect for snacking!"

"I truly enjoy the flavor and freshness of these cookies."

"The texture is fairly soft, which I appreciate."

"I find the packaging of 2 cookies very convenient for keeping them fresh."